Connect with us


College Board responds to backlash over AP African American studies curriculum : NPR



#Faculty #Board #responds #backlash #African #American #research #curriculum #NPR

NPR’s Mary Louise Kelly speaks with Faculty Board CEO David Coleman and director of Superior Placement African American Research Brandi Waters about curriculum modifications which have drawn criticism.


Let’s flip now to the backlash the Faculty Board is going through over its new AP course in African American research. The Faculty Board oversees the SAT and the AP, the Superior Placement program. And this week, it launched a revised curriculum for the African American research class. Critics have mentioned a pilot of this system that launched final 12 months included sure themes, sure authors. They observe the up to date framework has eliminated a few of them. And the timing of the Faculty Board’s press launch unveiling the up to date framework occurred to return after Florida Governor Ron DeSantis threatened to ban the course, saying it was, quote, “indoctrinating” college students. Nicely, the Faculty Board is defending the modifications.

And with me now to debate is Faculty Board CEO David Coleman. Welcome to you.


KELLY: And likewise senior director of the AP African American research program, Brandi Waters. Brandi Waters, welcome to you.

BRANDI WATERS: Thanks very a lot.

KELLY: Brandi, I’ll begin with you. I do know we have managed to catch you in a automotive, so we recognize your taking the time. However folks questioning in regards to the noise behind you, that is what is going on on. Earlier than we get into all of the controversy and the backwards and forwards this week, would you again up and simply lay out for us, what had been the targets? What was the unique pondering while you had been attempting to develop and roll out this new AP course on African American research?

WATERS: Certain. That is such a vibrant and attention-grabbing discipline that we appeared into creating a brand new course in African American research many, a few years in the past. Since then, we have discovered a whole lot of curiosity from college students and educators who persistently requested a brand new AP course on this discipline. And, in fact, it is actually aligned with our mission to create these alternatives for college students to tackle an in-depth examine in an space of their curiosity. And this can be a actually nice alternative to additionally give them an opportunity to earn school credit score and to really feel far more ready to achieve success as they pursue this course of examine in school as properly. So there was a whole lot of curiosity round this discipline and in addition coming from college students and academics.

KELLY: OK. So to this week and the political tensions – and, David, I’ll convey you in on this one. As I nodded to, Governor DeSantis threatened to ban the unique course. He talked in regards to the political agenda that he thought it was contributing to. The training commissioner for Florida spoke of, and I’m quoting, “woke indoctrination masquerading as training.” The criticism got here, after which this week, y’all unveiled a modified curriculum. So your critics are suggesting that you’ve got caved to political stress. Did you?

COLEMAN: We started the modifications which might be being mentioned in September of the earlier 12 months, led by the committee that’s growing the course. There is a committee of school. And people modifications had been largely full by December, and now we have these time-stamped supplies. Far earlier than the governor spoke up, we might introduced that we had been going to launch the revised framework on the primary day of Black Historical past Month, as we did. So it is merely…

KELLY: So to – simply – sorry, simply to pause for a minute…


KELLY: …As a result of this feels vital – you might be saying, look; we had a pilot program. We had been, , in search of suggestions. We made some modifications…

COLEMAN: Precisely.

KELLY: …And now we have paperwork to indicate we had been making these modifications earlier than this criticism got here in from Florida.

COLEMAN: There are time stamps. There’s clear proof. So it’s merely false that the modifications had been made after, so simply so we do not get confused.

However I believe your most vital assertion was the concept that authors had been banned, Black authors had been banned. This cost of censorship, this notion that authors have been reduce out is the one I would like to handle most forcefully in the present day and clear up in case you’ll give me a minute to do this. Would that be OK?

KELLY: Certain. And simply to be clear, I did not say they had been banned. I mentioned some…

COLEMAN: Or eliminated.

KELLY: …Some that had been within the authentic curriculum are now not in it.

COLEMAN: Proper.

KELLY: That is correct.

COLEMAN: And I am saying, no, it isn’t correct. Let me make clear in regards to the Black authors for a second ‘trigger we have actually thrilling information to make clear on your listeners what is going on on. Due to this confusion that considerate authors like Kimberle Crenshaw, for instance, on intersectionality, or bell hooks or different thinkers are someway now not represented within the framework, we took out all secondary sources, whether or not it was by Skip Gates or Evelyn Higginbotham, no matter their political qualities.

However there is a free useful resource known as AP Classroom, and each trainer and pupil in AP African American research goes to have entry to it. And now we have already purchased the permissions for texts like Kimberle Crenshaw’s breakthrough piece on – “Mapping The Margins,” on intersectionality. And they’ll be freely accessible to college students and academics all through the course. Audre Lorde’s poems – sources that folks had been frightened are gone are literally going to be magnified and made extra accessible than ever within the classroom and instructing assets, which is the place secondary sources in AP all the time are.

KELLY: For the avoidance of doubt, have any authors, any Black writers, been stricken, banned from the course?

COLEMAN: No authors have been banned from the course. And actually, we will carry them up and make them freely accessible.

WATERS: I would like to additionally simply paint a broader image of what David is explaining. We have streamlined the framework, as David talked about, to concentrate on major sources. These major sources based mostly on on a regular basis life is what actually opens up college students’ understanding for greater ideas and theories. And so as to make it possible for they’ve a deeper alternative to discover these initiatives, we have named them in an inventory of prompt initiatives, and we have really supplied these secondary sources on AP Classroom. I believe our hope is that by offering them on AP Classroom, they will be capable to look to those sources first, the place they will be capable to spend far more time on these subjects.

KELLY: For folks attempting to observe all this, let me simply put a primary query, a sure or no query, and you’ll every take it. Was the curriculum modified to appease Governor DeSantis or different critics who’ve accused the Faculty Board of being woke, sure or no?


WATERS: Completely not.

KELLY: If I may push you on this yet another time, to those that have a look at the modifications and the way they monitor very intently to the modifications that Ron DeSantis was arguing for, it is a coincidence?

COLEMAN: Let me attempt to clarify. What was attacked had been secondary sources and all of the secondary sources. What was not mentioned in all of the political commentary was the core details and proof of the course. Everybody’s in settlement. Evidently that was brilliantly dealt with.

There have been some commentators that had been attacked, however these had been all a part of secondary sources we by no means record. We took out all of the secondary sources, together with ones that by no means bought remark ‘trigger we do not do it in any AP course. In AP historical past, AP U.S. historical past or AP English, we give a core set of major sources just like the books you learn or artwork you have a look at, however we do not record precisely what teachers you learn and which articles ‘trigger that will be the Faculty Board creating the one record or canon of scholarly work. We supplied it to the pilot academics as a assist, however we by no means do it when now we have an official framework.

KELLY: Brandi, I will provide you with the final phrase. And I ponder in case you would communicate on to college students who could also be contemplating taking the course, who could, within the midst of all this controversy, be questioning what they’re strolling into and whether or not they’re studying as a lot as they may. What would you need them to know?

WATERS: Certain. I’d inform college students that is essentially the most coherent narrative of African American historical past, tradition, politics and authorized research that I’ve seen for highschool college students; that that is an thrilling alternative for them to have a look at over 100 assets, whether or not or not it’s artworks or datasets, that showcase the variety of Black life and the contributions made not solely in america, but additionally broadly; that these college students have a chance to study much more than what’s been circulated because the very first model of the pilot. So if they’ve questions on how we’re all linked, about how this discipline was fashioned and about the place the sector goes, that is an thrilling course to take to have actually nice discussions in regards to the bigger trajectory of our society in the present day.

KELLY: That’s Brandi Waters, senior director of AP African American research for the Faculty Board, talking with us from a automotive, and the CEO of the Faculty Board, David Coleman, who was with us as properly. Due to you each.

COLEMAN: Thanks.

WATERS: Thanks.

Copyright © 2023 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site terms of use and permissions pages at for additional info.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content will not be in its closing kind and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could differ. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.