Murray Mandryk: Tossing more money at public health care is not reform

Article content material

Premier Scott Moe stunned some along with his optimistic tones on Sunday, prior to departing for the federal-provincial health-care funding meeting.

Article content material

Optimism isn’t precisely what we’ve been listening to from Moe or most different premiers with regards to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s administration.

Article content material

Furthermore, no matter optimistic confidence the general public right here could have within the Saskatchewan Get together authorities’s supply of well being care was badly shaken final week.

The Canadian Press story that Well being Minister Paul Merriman and this government initially ignored federal government offers of help in the fall of 2021 to cope with hospital over-capacity because of COVID-19 certainly rattled the notion of a authorities solely targeted on good health-care outcomes.

As for the broader health-care reform we’ve heard about from Moe and the opposite premiers — two-thirds of whom are of of the conservative bent  — the kindest factor to say is it’s been merely about getting extra Canada Well being Switch (CHT) {dollars} from Ottawa.

Article content material

To provincial politicians, {dollars} equals optimism. Getting extra of them solely feeds the narrative we are actually listening to from federal Conservative Chief Pierre Poilievre that “every thing is damaged.”

Perhaps the issue is we haven’t been listening to sufficient from voices much less involved with politics and extra about true health-care reform. Maybe now is an effective time to reintroduce you to 1.

Peter Nicholson has held an astounding variety of senior administrative positions in authorities, enterprise and training, starting from advisor to the prime minister’s workplace to government positions at ScotiaBank and BCE Inc. to founding the Council of Canadian Academies.

Final month, Nicholson offered a coverage transient for the College of Regina’s Johnson-Shoyama Graduate Faculty of Public Coverage aptly entitled “Repairing Well being Care in Canada: Time to Take the First Step.”

Article content material

That first step, in keeping with Nicholson’s transient, is to “begin doing issues in another way” by recognizing that public well being care in Canada wants reform — not greater transfers from Ottawa to the provinces that accomplish little aside from hammering taxpayers.

“What has been uncovered is an unwelcome fact: Canada doesn’t have a world-class health-care system,” Nicholson bluntly wrote. “For well being care to be a defining ingredient of Canada’s nationwide delight and id, as many imagine it to be, we owe it to ourselves to do rather a lot higher.”

Doing higher requires acceptance of the notion that the “general efficiency of well being care in Canada (is) close to the underside amongst our peer group of economically superior nations, above solely the USA,” Nicholson wrote. Reform is required, however “the health-care system has confirmed remarkably immune to vital reform.”

Article content material

Federal cash “has diminished the motivation for reform” so the CHT ought to be changed by a mixture of a “switch of tax ‘room’ or ‘tax factors’ ” to the provinces and enhancements to the equalization formulation, he stated.

“The brand new association would finish the CHT mythology that the funds, as soon as within the palms of the provinces, are reserved solely for well being care,” Nicholson stated within the transient.

“For purely political causes, provinces have nonetheless welcomed an annual block of money with out accountability for the tax charges wanted to fund it.”

However, most intriguingly, Nicholson takes sq. goal on the notion that we are able to’t or shouldn’t have some “quantity of medically essential care exterior the general public system” that truly exists in Australia, Germany and Norway the place’s there’s a lot higher voter satisfaction with their public health-care methods.

Article content material

This false impression that “‘non-public’, in a health-care context, equals ‘American’  … has made it nearly not possible to even think about reform,” Nicholson added.

He concluded by saying that “what ought to be carried out is well-known,” however there’s a “lack of political incentive to alter.”

Perhaps plenty of Canada’s well being care is damaged, nevertheless it’s nothing that may’t be fastened although financing reform and rethinking the position of personal insurance coverage in our public system.

Think about if the premiers emerged from this assembly with a new-found dedication to such significant reform. Now, that may be trigger for optimism.

Mandryk is the political columnist for the Regina Chief-Submit and the Saskatoon StarPhoenix.

Join the Regina Chief-Submit Afternoon Headlines e-newsletter. Click here to subscribe.

Join the Saskatoon StarPhoenix Afternoon Headlines e-newsletter. Click here to subscribe.