Phil Tank: Saskatoon city hall feud looks petty amid housing crisis

Article content material

It appears applicable that the newest chapter in an apparently ongoing feud between Saskatoon metropolis corridor and a developer revolves round sewage.

Article content material

And Saskatoon’s municipal authorities ought to put on the stench of this explicit dispute with Vancouver-based Arbutus Properties Ltd., after a profitable enchantment of a metropolis council resolution that halted work on a undertaking that features inexpensive housing.

Article content material

You learn that proper: in a nation acknowledged as affected by a housing disaster on account of an absence of provide, Saskatoon metropolis council tried to impede the addition of 244 inexpensive housing models.

In a choice launched this week, based mostly on a Dec. 8 hearing, town’s improvement appeals board granted the enchantment by Arbutus of a 9-1 October metropolis council resolution that put the brakes on development of an house advanced within the Rosewood neighbourhood.

The dispute focuses on the constructing of sewer infrastructure that Arbutus agreed to undertake to ensure that the undertaking to proceed to fulfill deadlines to achieve inexpensive housing funding from the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Company.

Article content material

The four-member enchantment board granted the enchantment by Arbutus and ordered metropolis council to go a bylaw inside a month that may enable the event to proceed.

Arbutus can be directed to pay $1.3 million in excellent improvement levies associated to the undertaking inside seven days of passage of the bylaw permitting work to start.

The board discovered the enchantment met three key necessities: particularly, that it didn’t characterize “particular privilege” for the corporate, that it didn’t critically contravene the zoning bylaw and that it could not hurt neighbouring properties.

So it seems the event will proceed, barring extra metropolis corridor obstruction.

Town’s objections to requests by Arbutus to bend the standard guidelines appeared based mostly on an alleged purity within the interpretation of zoning and improvement guidelines. Anybody who’s watched metropolis corridor for even a bit of little bit of time is aware of that’s not actuality.

Article content material

In an attention-grabbing twist, former mayor Don Atchison appeared on behalf of Arbutus on the December listening to.

Atchison, who obtained a $5,000 donation from Arbutus for his third-place 2020 mayoral election marketing campaign, urged town was failing to offer the identical lodging for Arbutus as had been afforded different builders.

Saskatoon’s longest-serving mayor, who misplaced the 2016 and 2020 elections to Mayor Charlie Clark, additionally confused the necessity for inexpensive housing in Saskatoon.

Though considerations about an untenable precedent that will probably be exploited by future builders appear respectable, there’s too many examples of metropolis corridor bending its personal guidelines to take that too severely. Possibly Vancouver builders don’t get the identical consideration.

Article content material

Atchison pointed to developments in The Willows and Stonebridge neighbourhoods as examples of rule-bending.

However this week’s improvement appeals board ruling brings with it some vital potential ramifications.

Apparently, it arrives lower than a month after a Court docket of King’s Bench choose dismissed an attempt to power the inclusion of considerable funding to finish homelessness in Regina in that metropolis’s 2023 finances.

Arbutus has additionally linked progress on the Rosewood undertaking to a different long-standing obsession for Saskatoon — the corporate’s plan for a downtown grocery store seen as essential to boosting residence within the core.

So the developer appears poised to assist metropolis corridor obtain a few of its key targets, like downtown progress, infill and adequate housing provide, regardless of this seemingly petty feud.

Article content material

Just a few years in the past, Arbutus tried to pitch a unique solar community in Saskatoon, solely to be rebuffed by a metropolis corridor seemingly aghast {that a} developer would counsel growing land out of sequence simply because it’s been performed earlier than.

Metropolis corridor virtually sneered on the estimated $1 billion funding related to the photo voltaic group.

Just lately, housing provide has turn out to be a nationwide preoccupation.

Federal Conservative Chief Pierre Poilievre has gained traction along with his promise to hyperlink federal funding for municipalities to eradicating obstacles to housing development.

Saskatoon has now turn out to be a shining instance of a metropolis corridor keen to impede housing development for doubtful causes.

Phil Tank is the digital opinion editor on the Saskatoon StarPhoenix.

[email protected]

twitter.com/thinktankSK

Wish to know the way we determine what to cowl and the way editorial selections are made on the Saskatoon StarPhoenix and Regina Chief-Publish? Get the weekly Letter From the Editor e-newsletter from the Editor in Chief Russell Wangersky and be a part of the dialogue on what goes into overlaying information and delivering commentary, each in print and on-line. Click here to subscribe.